DIY Nativity Puppets

Last year we made what might be my favorite project ever, our Painted Nativity Set! This year, now that I have Jasper, I wanted to create something that was a bit more child-friendly: Nativity puppets!

Learn how to make these Nativity puppets in the tutorial below! Plus, we’ve linked some other Nativity crafts to create this holiday!

I was inspired by these ornaments to create puppets using paper mache balls. I’ve been wanting to do this forever, only to find out my good friend, Merrilee had already done something similar! Great minds think alike! I enlisted the talented Michelle Christensen of My Little Belleville to illustrate the faces for each character in the Nativity. To turn them into puppets, we drilled a hole into each sphere, inserted a pencil, and clothed each one in a simple fabric tunic. So simple! Jasper is already a big fan.

DIY Nativity Puppets


  • Paper Mache Spheres–We included 7 characters
  • Acrylic Paints
  • Paintbrushes
  • Electric Drill
  • #2 pencils
  • Fabric–We used 7 different varieties
  • Sewing machine or needle and thread
  • Glue gun


  1. Paint each ball as a member of the nativity using the acrylic paints. Let dry
  2. Using an electric drill, drill a hole in the center base of each face, just wide enough to fit a pencil through snuggly. We used a Drillbit.
  3. Insert a pencil into each one and set aside.
  4. Cut each type of fabric into an 18″ by 10″ piece.
  5. Finish the 18-inch long sides of the fabric by folding under 1/4-inch and sewing. This is optional but creates a cleaner finish.
  6. Then fold each piece of fabric in half longways, with right sides together, and stitch so you create a cylinder of fabric.
  7. Iron the seam allowance open so it lays flat.
  8. Sew a gathering stitch (using a long seam allowance) along the top of the fabric cylinder.
  9. Gather the top by pulling the bobbin threads tightly so the top part cinches together.
  10. Slide the pencil into the fabric and hot glue the gathered portion to the base of the head.

Now every Christmas you can put on a Nativity show, without worrying about breaking any delicate pieces! For more Nativity crafts, check out these Nativity clothespin dolls and this mid-century heirloom Nativity!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Trending Articles

DIY Beaded Chandelier

The Inspiration You've probably seen this amazing bead chandelier before, as it has made its way around the internet (others found here and here and...

DIY Family Photo Heirloom Ornaments

A Literal Family Tree This time of year always tends to be a bit nostalgic. It's a time for family, which got me thinking about...

Recent Articles

Envelope pillow case

How to make an envelope pillow case This envelope pillow case tutorial is one of the easiest ways to make a pillow case because you...

Lime Ricki launch party

Lime Ricki Launch Party! We held our launch party the day the collection debuted. The event captured the energy we've been experiencing behind the scenes....